Guest article: Black-Green is a coalition of higher earners – WELT


sBlack and green have been the “coveted alliance” of the greens of North Rhine-Westphalia from the very beginning. Why? Felix Banasczak 2022, who was still president of the Green State Federation, said it was the only possible way to vote from the age of 16. The SPD votes in the bag anyway, but only with the CDU as government partner would there be the necessary two-thirds majority. This is an amazingly honest and meaningful justification, because it reveals a few things about green priorities: “Affordable housing” is also an issue with the Green Elections platform, but does it make government participation dependent on it? The party didn’t even come up with the idea.

More than ten million people live in rented accommodation in North Rhine-Westphalia, and more than a million in Schleswig-Holstein. The former black-and-yellow government in North Rhine-Westphalia and Jamaica in the north each took away property rights from their tenants wherever they could. Since then, rents have risen more than they have in decades. Good and affordable Newly built apartments It practically does not exist for middle-income families. Neither in the west nor in the north.

Read also

Frederik Merz (left) and Hendrik Fust (both CDU)

It is the worst housing shortage in decades. This does improve a bit under black and green. New construction flats with rent control at a record low, tenant protection as bad as it was in the last legislative term. The Green Party in North Rhine-Westphalia decided to vote 16 in the north in favor of another ministry. In return, the CDU is allowed to continue the policy of free housing in North Rhine-Westphalia, and in the north the black and green delay the minimum privileges that the tenants’ association wrested from the coalition with the promised reintroduction of the cap.

In the Climate protection The same. Instead of protecting people from the ban on gas heating by building climate-neutral heating networks, millions in Schleswig-Holstein with the “Climate Protection for Citizens” program are distributed to wealthy clients of the CDU and the Greens, who can thus get more financing for their heat pump or photovoltaic – Get to the station. People who live to rent or don’t have any money on edge to fund their own contribution to support go empty-handed.

Read also

Alexander Dobrindt, 53, chair of the CSU state group in the Bundestag

This is the pattern of black-and-green politics: it is a policy for well-to-do publics, who are aware of the fears of holding back from reading newspapers, are willing to invest in renewable energies themselves and expect “sustainability”—that is, disciplined spending—from the state. There is a bit of law and order for the average conservative public, and a bit of progressive social politics for urban academia, as long as it costs nothing and hurts nobody.

What there isn’t – and there isn’t in any country ruled by black and green: relief for working families, laws to comply with collective bargaining, educational programs for more equal opportunity, investments in climate protection for all or active industrial policy. Black-Green is not an alliance of people who are concerned about their rents, price hikes, or educational opportunities their children do.

Constant annoying argument for the traffic light

Yet observers treat this alliance as a “future alliance” for the federal government. On the one hand, this is due to the constantly annoying row over traffic lights, and on the other hand, to the political style of the two prime ministers, Daniel Gunther and Hendrik Fuest. Both adhere to Gunther’s credo: stay out of culture wars, “stay linguistically clean” and – as it is no longer a matter of course in the Meers-Söder union – “don’t tell people shit”.

Wüst and Günther are two nice people who say nice things. For example, that all children in our country are “our children”, no matter what they are called. You can even believe that they actually consider Salih, Eileen, and Mustafa to be their own countrymen. They do not want to do anything for their educational success.

No federal state’s education system is in such a serious crisis as it is in NRW: education tests are disastrous, day care centers are writing fiery letters, and there are fewer equal opportunities than ever. Schleswig-Holstein is also located in Education direction IQB Back. Although the situation is bad and unfair, not much is being done about it. The participation of the Green Party in government did not change anything here or there. on the contrary. If you keep education resources scarce, prioritize. Perhaps Salih, Aylin and Mustafa’s parents don’t vote at all. On the other hand, Louis, Finn and Sophie’s parents definitely do. Greens also depend on this.

Read also

Historical shock

When the CDU and Greens rule together, they allegedly do not differ much. They are surprisingly similar in style and content: gentle, ecological and neoliberal. For that matter, you don’t need much imagination to imagine what the federal government’s black-and-green politics would look like. The well-known pact essence of the countries was renewed: conservative economic and social policy against moderately progressive environmental and social policy.

There will be no shortage of commitments to diversity and universality. Nor will the expansion of renewable energies, which has accelerated at a traffic light, be reversed. In turn, the Federation may implement tax reform plans: mSevere tax cuts For those with high and high incomes. The Greens will not oppose this. Why ? Their constituents also benefit. And how! The gaps in the billions that reform will rip into the budget must be filled by cuts elsewhere.

family policy? no one

It’s not hard to imagine how Daniel Bayaz (Greens) and Carsten Linnemann (CDU) together explain why the abolition of the pension at 63, the reduction of benefits for statutory health insurers and the abolition of the tax credit for night and shift allowances are “sustainable” and “intergenerational” imperatives. justice”.

In short: Black-Green is an alliance of the highest earners, for their reckoning and, above all, for their conscience. There will be no policy for employees and their families. Nor is it a political concept that underpins individualism in our time in solidarity, which combines the remarkable freedom of the individual with the power of solidarity, and which holds elites responsible for the advancement of the many.

Black-Green can’t and doesn’t want to. On the other hand, the Social Democratic government does. It is the Social Democratic Party that wants to reconcile opposites, that wants to lead the way without leaving others behind. Just like a traffic light – even if it gets louder at times, it sways and rattles. This keeps democracy alive, and also arouses opposition, but above all participation and solutions.

Jochen Ott leads the parliamentary group of the SPD in North Rhine-Westphalia and Thomas Los Müller in Schleswig-Holstein.

Read also

From left: AfD faction leader in Thuringia Bjorn Hockey, appointed AfD district director in Sonneberg, Robert Stallmann, CDU leader Friedrich Merz


Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *